By Faustino Galante
I’m not a huge fan of Halloween. I hate horror, I’m not really a candy buff and in my opinion, most Halloween costumes nowadays lack originality and humor (and fear, for that matter). Despite my opinions of the festivities, I have always celebrated this senseless holiday. This past year, my friends and I decided to hit the streets of the Bronx in full mariachi gear (sombreros and Mexican capes). Our intention was simple: find a semi-comedic costume for a cheap price. Many people, though our goals were directed elsewhere. They beleives that the costumes stereotyped and mocked the average Mexican citizen. Throughout the night, we were subject to various criticisms and condemned as “racists.”
I took much offense to the ludicrous claims made by these argumentative people. Getting into political and philosophical debates was not something I was interested in doing at a Halloween party (Fordham’s “Core Curriculum” provides enough of this during the scholastic week). The various controversies our costumes evoked led me to think deeply about the racial climate present within our nation. After some careful thought, I came to two main conclusions: political polarization has spurred racial hostility, and people have forgotten the true nature of what it means to be a “melting pot,” consequently becoming too sensitive.
Political polarization refers to extreme political ideological divides within society. According to the Pew Research Center, Republicans and Democrats are more divided today than at any other point in the past two decades. This should not come as a surprise to most people. Look at this year’s election, for example: it epitomizes both the hostility and extreme ideologies derived from political polarization within our society.
Unfortunately, polarization seems to have not only affected how Washington deals with situations (with much dysfunction), but has also impacted how citizens live in accordance with one another. In regards to racial hostilities, in particular, our current two-party system has divided the public on this issue. People who lean left are often categorized as being too sensitive when it comes to racial relations. When one thinks of the word “triggered,” a liberal usually comes to mind. On the other side of the spectrum, conservatives are scorned for being rich, white racists who look to undermine social peace in America. These polarized claims are, in my opinion, one of the reasons people took offense to the mariachi Halloween costumes. People saw us, judged us as being “far right bastards,” and decided to slander us with politically charged rage. Because race has become subject to the political polarization of this country, racial relations have worsened. This year’s election has not helped direct the country towards societal peace.
In the fourth grade, one of my clearest memories of history class (other than the Erie Canal Song) was learning about the idea of America being a “melting pot.” Unfortunately, many of the aspects of the American “melting pot” are no longer present in our country. This has led to the intensification of racial hostilities. Racial strife occurred throughout the 20th century, but this period encouraged cultural assimilation. People, specifically during the 1960s, 70s and 80s, looked to discover what other cultures had to offer. Ramen noodles became popular and culturally themed parties became a frequent occurrence. People came to take pride in the fact that America was made up of various different cultures. Most cultures during this period were not angered at this “cultural appropriation,” so to speak.
Today, people are not as enthusiastic about cultural assimilation. Just yesterday, I heard about an Indian student who took offense to white Americans playing music of his culture. People in this country have become too sensitive and need to re-embrace the “melting pot” version of American society. If the “melting pot” were welcomed, I can almost guarantee that people would not have taken offense to my Halloween costume the other night.
It seems as though nothing nowadays can go on without offending some person or group. I guess I’ll just be a ghost for Halloween next year. Hopefully the spirits don’t find it discriminating.
Dr. Necessitor • Nov 7, 2016 at 9:09 pm
Celebrating Halloween is cultural appropriation unless you are of Celtic (incl. Gaelic) descent. So if other ethnicities and races can’t play nice and have fun without being buzzkills, we will take Halloween back.
Claudia Bennett • Nov 5, 2016 at 10:20 pm
This kid really does not get it.
The reason why people were offended at his costume wasn’t because cultures shouldn’t be mixed, it was because he was making light of a culture as a joke. He said himself that he and his friends were looking for comedic costumes, but why did they think a Mexican stereotype was so humorous? The author and his friends wore part of a culture as a joke, and that is why people are offended. Not because of the political polarization in America.
Actual mixing of cultures in a melting pot society would be appreciating and learning about a culture, not dressing up as it for Halloween. If the author read about the history of mariachi bands, listened to their music, paid to go see an authentic one live, or even took the time to learn an instrument and join one themselves it would not be considered offensive. All those instances are an example of taking part in a culture and appreciating it, something that the multi-cultural society of America allows and why we are so celebrated as being a “melting pot”.
We are so privileged as a country, and especially in New York City to be surrounded by people from countless other cultures. But to enjoy this privileged we must be respectful and willing to learn from a culture rather than just creating a few stereotypical views about each culture we encounter. Just dressing up as a culture you are not a part of because you think it is funny is indeed offensive because it shows you do not know enough about that culture to respect it.
The fact that this author didn’t listen to the people who were offended and instead chose to defend his position by blaming the political climate of america is the actual reason why this country is so polarized. People like the author would rather go to all lengths to defend themselves rather than admit that something they did was offensive and learn from it. He calls the people with complaints about cultural appropriation “too sensitive” but in reality the only sensitive one is the author who would rather immediately put down those that criticism him instead of stopping to think about if their point is valid. Maybe if the author paid more attention to those Fordham “Core Curriculum” classes he wants to forget about so bad, he would know how to conduct a constructive dialogue and stop some of the polarization he complains about.
Ben Arisen (@BrightLeaf88) • Nov 5, 2016 at 11:31 pm
Why do you think you can speak for Mexicans about what is or is not offensive to them? I know actual Mexican immigrants and none of them care at all about this shit. The only people I have seen get triggered about cultural appropriation are white college girls.
Chad Wilson • Nov 16, 2016 at 11:32 pm
“This kid really does not get it” Try to be a little more condescending next time but before you do learn how to make a rational, eloquent argument
g • Nov 5, 2016 at 9:35 pm
This reads like someone who was embarrassed after being accused of cultural appropriation and the only way he knew how to handle it was to write an article trying to defend his racist costume and explain why it was okay. I’m sorry your pride was hurt, I’m sorry you can’t entertain the possibility that you might have been wrong. But it is not your place to tell someone what should or shouldn’t be offending them. Take them at their word and learn from your mistake. That’s a demonstration of basic respect and some semblance of maturity.
cn • Nov 5, 2016 at 7:56 pm
Not to be that person, but to be that person, the melting pot analogy is not an accurate description of what American culture is. Our culture is more of a salad bowl; there is a mixing of cultures, but more often than not when people come to the US, they maintain distinctive traditions from their home country. Cultures have never melted together here, but have instead become “Americanized” (the dressing in a salad b/c it goes all over everything). We are not becoming sensitized to race and culture, appropriation is just getting more attention now. No one claimed blackface was wrong in the early 1900s, but that didn’t mean it didn’t hurt an entire race. When you dress up in “mariachi gear,” you are essentially mocking the history and culture of another country. Culture is not a costume. It never has been and never will. We are just more conscious now– the world is changing. Maybe, you should be too.
Also, we have the core curriculum for a reason and that is to make us question and ponder the world around us. That is why so many Fordham students debated you on this. This embarrasses not only The Ram but the entire Fordham community. Shame on you. Also, get an editor this is poorly written/ organized and your logic doesn’t make sense. Did you even take comp II? Probably not.
John • Nov 5, 2016 at 12:49 pm
Does anyone edit these articles? This article is so laughably awful and so poorly written that it should be an embarrassment to the Ram.
S. • Nov 5, 2016 at 12:41 pm
I find it ironic that people accuse others of cultural appropriation on Halloween, when most people don’t even know what they’re celebrating on October 31st. In some respect, their celebrations of a secularized Halloween make them victims of “cultural appropriation” to begin with, since they’re using a religious/pagan holiday as an excuse to get dolled up and party. I myself do not know in detail what the holiday celebrates, and continue to celebrate it, but I think there is a definite double standard in this country on what is and what isn’t cultural appropriation.
Ben Arisen (@BrightLeaf88) • Nov 2, 2016 at 6:35 pm
America has never been a melting pot. It’s just a myth they teach to young children in schools. Violence and discontent have always existed everywhere cultures collide, and America’s entire past is a long example of this.